The odd thing about morals is that
so many people seem perfectly fine with arbitrariness. “I’ll just make up my
own version of right and wrong.” But the question remains, if you can
arbitrarily make it up, you can arbitrarily change it on a whim and anyone else can do the same with their system of morals. Are
you going to say that they’re “wrong” for doing so? Unless one has a standard
outside of themselves upon which to base a set of morals, any moral stance
taken is by definition, arbitrary and therefore without authority.
Considerations of life from an ex- Calvinist intellectual who is now a Deacon in the Russian Orthodox Church
Thursday, November 4, 2021
A Moral Foundation
Monday, November 1, 2021
Giving Advice
How do we respond
when someone holds a belief that is contrary to our own or simply is wrong?
First, it depends upon the person. If we are talking about a complete stranger
who has posted a thought on a social media account, there is no need to respond
unless they are specifically asking us for input or direction. If this person
is someone under our authority, we should direct them towards the truth. If
this is someone who is an equal and with whom we are in a relationship, it can
be brought up as a discussion point if they are interested in dialog. If they
are not, we need to let it go. If this is a spouse and the point needs to be
resolved, it can only be resolved if both people are interested in resolving
it. In short, unrequested advice is nothing but imposition.
Wednesday, October 27, 2021
Thoughts, Speech, and Grace
Whenever we speak and whenever we act, we are doing so,
hopefully, with the best of intentions. We speak or act those things that we
believe to be the best word or action for the moment we are in. But far too
often, this is not actually the case because we are very limited in our wisdom
and understanding.
Realizing this, we should be far more gracious toward others.
We can easily see, and critique others mistakes but, for some reason, we want
grace and sympathy from others when we err. Our grace to others should far, far
surpass the grace we give to ourselves.
Friday, October 22, 2021
Truth in the Arts
Over the years I
have argued for the importance of truth in art. Every song, every story, every
movie, every sculpture or painting or photograph needs to be true. And when I
say true, I don’t mean ‘historically accurate’, I mean that the story that is
being told by the work of art must be foundationally (or to use a technical
term, metaphorically) true.
For example, the “Lord
of the Rings” books are true works of art. Obviously, they are not historically
accurate but the foundational story that they tell is true. When a work of art
is true, it faithfully represents human nature, it exists in a world in which
evil is truly evil and has ultimately been defeated and God is in control.
This is the real
danger of American culture. So much of the music that is made, the books that
are written and the movies that are created do not tell the truth. When we
subject ourselves to a steady diet of untruth, we are shaping our thinking to
align with falsity. We are slowly confusing ourselves and moving ourselves away
from the pursuit of holiness.
We have one thing
to do in our time on this planet, we are to love others. That’s it. That’s all.
And by all means possible, do not let the worldview of American culture define “love”
for you. God is love, not lust, not emotion, not happy feelings. To love
someone is to do what you can for them that will move them toward holiness.
Saturday, October 16, 2021
Life, Death, and Eternity
It is unfortunate and
misleading that our existence after death is so often presented as terrifying
and dark. So much of what is believed about our state after death was
fabricated in the last 500 years by those who did not understand the nature of
God and the nature of his relationship with man. Jesus Christ, because of his
resurrection and ascension, defeated the power of death, freeing us from its
grasp.
Our state after
death is based on two things. First, our life after physical death is eternal.
Death was defeated so death will never overpower us. We will never cease to be.
Second, the way that we choose to live our lives in this lifetime will form our
souls into the state we will be for eternity. If we have chosen to serve only
ourselves, if we have chosen to seek after pleasure, and if we have chosen to ignore
the pursuit of holiness, we will endure an eternity in the presence of the one
holy God that will feel unbearable. If we spend our mortal lives ignoring God and
living in selfishness, our eternity in the immediate presence of the one holy
God will be contrary to how we have formed ourselves.
When we read of an
eternity in the fires of hell, it is important to remember that this is a
metaphor, an illustration to help us understand how unholy men will feel in the
presence of holiness. It is not literal fire, it is not suffering at the hands of
demons, and it is certainly not suffering under the wrath of a vengeful God.
God is love and the suffering we will endure will be because we neglected to receive
the love and relationship that he offers us.
Our state after
physical death is eternal life, temporary disembodied but eventually reunited
body and soul. But the quality of that experience is our own responsibility. Whether
our eternity feels like heaven or feels like hell our eternal state is simply the
fruit of a lifetime of response to the love of God.
Saturday, October 9, 2021
Self Assessment and Judgment
Take a thorough look at your life and assess if you are growing or not. Do you see change in your life? Do you see yourself becoming stronger, smarter, wiser, or more loving? Has your thinking changed since you were in high school? Are you less judgmental and more considerate? Do you have sympathy for others and their shortcomings? Do you judge yourself more harshly than you did when you were younger?
A life that is changing in comparison to one that is not, can be likened to a river that is flowing, shifting, changing and finding the best path versus a pond that only sits stagnant and generates scum.
Saturday, October 2, 2021
Identifying Christian Belief and Practice
If someone said, “I believe that the rules for the NFL are “x,
y, and z” and someone else says, “No, you’re wrong, they are “a, b, and c”,
only one of them is correct but they could both be wrong. Why is that? Because
those who are the actual authorities over how the NFL is defined have clearly
articulated the rules. The understanding of and articulation of, those rules
are up to just anyone but those in authority.
In the same way, when one group of people who call
themselves Christians say that Christian belief and practice is “x, y, and z”
and another group says, “No, you’re wrong, they are “a, b, and c”, only one of
them is correct but they could both be wrong. How is this resolved?
It is certainly not resolved by appealing to “well, the
Bible says this”, or “well, this is the way we have always done it.” One cannot
simply appeal to the Bible because sin the Protestant Reformation, the idea of
private interpretation has become the presumed right of every believer. But
this, in itself, is a presumption that may or may not be correct. And as far as
antiquity of practice goes, simply because one branch of Christians has believed
and practiced a certain thing for a long time does not make it true.
I argue that we are approaching the question from the wrong
direction. If we start at the beginning, we end up in a very different place.
Beginning with the belief that Jesus Christ is a real person who actually exists,
we can build an interesting argument.
1) Jesus taught his disciples specific truths.
2) His disciples, becoming apostles, took those
teachings and began to teach others across the known world.
3) That teaching became known as ‘Christianity’ and
was embraced by some and rejected by others.
4) That teaching, over time, began to be twisted
and maligned so that the leaders of the church (a hierarchy established by the
apostles), needed to articulate, and identify what actually was Christian
belief. We see this in the seven ecumenical councils of the first eight
centuries of the church.
5) Jesus promised his followers that he would not
leave them alone but would give them the Holy Spirit to guide and protect them.
6) Jesus promised his followers that hell would never
prevail over the church.
So, we have to ask, because Jesus said and did these things,
do we believe what he taught them about faith and practice, and do we practice these things ourselves?