After thirty years as a Protestant
arguing and debating with other Protestants, evangelicals, and quasi-Christian
groups, it occurred to me that the problem was not the Scripture or the
Christian faith but the methodology and presumptions of so many that called
themselves Christians. The points of argumentation and debates always devolved
to the point of “this is how I interpret that passage and that is how you
interpret that passage”, in short, a stalemate.
Ultimately it came down to private
interpretation. Because there was no ultimate authority outside of the
individual’s interpretation, nothing could be resolved. Even in the off chance
that I would “win” an argument and convince someone to join my particular
version of Protestantism, the problem was still the same. The converting
individual was still in the same place of interpreting for themselves what the
Scriptures meant.
This explains the reason for the
existence of ten thousand different denominations, all calling themselves
followers of Jesus Christ. The problem is not the level of devotion or the
intent of each person, but of the foundational question of authority. To whom
do you look to rightly understand the Scriptures and Christian history? Do you
interpret these on your own, or do you look to that which the apostles handed
down to each generation?